Just like many of us, executives, agents and scouts around the NFL were amazed by some of the moves made across the league in the opening days of free agency.
We surveyed insiders around the NFL on who they think the winners and losers of free agency are to this point, along with which contracts they thought were the best and worst. One NFL executive lauded a team’s all-in approach, while an agent didn’t like one of the $100 million contracts handed out this week.
So, which teams improved the most in the first week of free agency? Which contract was the biggest overpay? Here’s what we learned in our conversations with executives, agents and scouts around the NFL.
***
Jets, Raiders get their rebuilds off to good begins: ‘They didn’t do something silly’
Ralph Vacchiano: The groups that spend probably the most in free company aren’t at all times those that do the most effective. In reality, some years the largest spenders flip into the largest flops.
However two groups that had cash to burn this week received optimistic evaluations from a number of NFL scouts and executives. So possibly there may be lastly some hope for the Las Vegas Raiders and the New York Jets.
“I’m not saying both of them will probably be good,” an assistant normal supervisor informed me. “However I preferred their method (to free company). They didn’t do something silly.”
The Jets, specifically, “utterly rebuilt their protection,” as one scout informed me, “however they did it with out taking an pointless massive swing. Each man they signed is a strong veteran participant. And none of them broke anybody’s financial institution.”
Their signings included linebacker Demario Davis (two years, $22 million), edge rusher Joseph Ossai (three years, $36 million), and a commerce for security Minkah Fitzpatrick (three years, $40 million). In addition they took a reasonable, one-year, $5.5 million shot at cornerback Nahshon Wright, who went to the Professional Bowl final yr.
5-time Professional Bowler Minkah Fitzpatrick was traded to the Jets earlier this week.. (Picture by Cooper Neill/Getty Photographs)
“Aaron Glenn is a defensive man, and he might see that after the trades final yr [of defensive tackle Quinnen Williams and cornerback Sauce Gardner], he had nothing to construct round,” an AFC govt informed me. “He nonetheless wants to search out stars, however now he has a basis, at the very least within the quick time period. He can begin to construct a program, even when most of those guys gained’t be round when the Jets are lastly good.”
The Jets didn’t get plenty of reward for his or her resolution to commerce for Geno Smith and make him their quarterback, however the govt informed me, “It’s not like that they had good choices. No less than he didn’t price them a lot.”
As for the Raiders, their state of affairs was sophisticated by the collapse of the Maxx Crosby commerce — a deal the assistant GM informed me “would’ve made their offseason a grand slam.” He mentioned their spending “was a bit crazier [than the Jets’], however that they had cap room to burn, so who cares? And if that they had gotten two first-round picks on high of that for a participant who didn’t need to be there? Wow.”
Even with out these picks, the Raiders nonetheless received the No. 1 middle available on the market (Tyler Linderbaum, three years, $81 million), a sleeper at receiver (Jalen Nailor, three years, $35 million) and a trio of strong defensive gamers (edge rusher Kwitty Paye for 3 years, $48 million; linbebacker Quay Walker for 3 years, $40.5 million and linebacker Nakobe Dean for 3 years, $36 million).
“They’re all concerning the quarterback,” the scout informed me of the Raiders, who’re anticipated to draft Fernando Mendoza with the primary decide of the draft. “However you may’t say ‘nothing else issues’. They wanted to repair the protection so they might maintain him in video games. They wanted to guard him. They needed to get him a receiver.
“Neglect the costs. They did all that. It wasn’t a franchise-changing [spending] spree, however it was a extremely strong begin.”
***
Rams make it clear they’re going for it once more
Vacchiano: The Los Angeles Rams know they’re loaded for a Super Bowl run, and so they knew their greatest drawback was their secondary.
Think about that gap plugged.
The Rams double-dipped at cornerback, buying and selling for Trent McDuffie (left) earlier than signing Jaylen Watson (proper). (Picture by Kevin Sabitus/Getty Photographs)
The Rams made an enormous, pre-market commerce for cornerback Trent McDuffie that price them a first-round decide and extra (to not point out the four-year, $124 million contract they gave him). Then they signed cornerback Jaylen Watson to a three-year, $51 million.
The strikes have been costly, however as one NFL govt informed me, “How will you not admire them for going for it? They know that with a 38-year-old quarterback, that is their final shot, possibly for a few years. So screw the longer term. Go for it now. In the event that they win the Tremendous Bowl, nobody will care in the event that they should endure for a few years.”
***
Extra winners and losers from free company
Vacchiano: A number of different groups got here up in conversations with league personnel about winners and losers in free company:
- The Pittsburgh Steelers earned high marks for signing running back Rico Dowdle and trading for wide receiver Michael Pittman. “Aaron Rodgers can’t carry them, and they know it,” one NFL executive told me. “They got him two weapons — a 1,000-yard rusher, and a No. 1 receiver who can be their No. 2 guy. Add in Mike McCarthy’s [offensive] teaching and so they’ll be a greater workforce.”
- The Kansas City Chiefs received some reward for signing working again Kenneth Walker as a result of, as one scout informed me, “he’s the kind of participant they’ve wanted for years.” However their secondary was decimated by the lack of McDuffie, Watson and security Bryan Cook. They misplaced LB Leo Chenal (Commanders), too. “Spags (defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo) has his work lower out for him,” the scout mentioned, “particularly if he can’t get that cross rush going once more.”
- One other workforce that misplaced far more gamers than they signed have been the Tremendous Bowl champion Seattle Seahawks, who watched Walker (Chiefs), security Coby Bryant (Bears), cornerback Riq Woolen (Eagles) and edge rusher Boye Mafe (Bengals) all go away within the first few days. “It’s the worth of profitable a championship,” an NFL govt informed me. “Everybody all of the sudden thinks they’re the most effective participant at their place. And everybody thinks they’re price greater than you do.”
***
Agent: Thumbs up on Malik Willis‘ deal to Dolphins
Eric D. Williams: In a quarterback market the place Kyler Murray and Tua Tagovailoa will make considerably extra money from their former groups whereas taking part in for his or her new groups and Daniel Jones signed a deal price as much as $100 million to remain in Indianapolis, an NFL agent pointed to a participant with solely six begins as top-of-the-line negotiated contracts in free company.
Sure, the Miami Dolphins‘ signing of Malik Willis to a three-year, $67.5 million contract that features $45 million in assured cash was top-of-the-line signings in free company.
“All of those offers are workouts in threat administration,” the agent informed me.
Malik Willis obtained the second-richest contract amongst quarterbacks in free company, however an agent actually preferred his contract. (Picture by Patrick McDermott/Getty Photographs)
And the Dolphins mitigated a few of that threat due to their familiarity with Willis. Head coach Jeff Hafley served because the defensive coordinator for the Green Bay Packers whereas Willis backed up Jordan Love at quarterback. And Dolphins normal supervisor Jon-Eric Sullivan labored as vice chairman of participant personnel for the Packers earlier than being employed by the Dolphins.
“Probably the most pragmatic deal can be Miami’s Malik Willis deal,” the agent informed me. “They may cope with the ramifications of a – in hindsight — dangerous QB deal [Tua] this yr. They did a superb job of being pragmatic of their new beginning QB deal for Willis.
“Given how costly and dangerous the QB market is, this Willis deal is spot on by way of correct worth whereas mitigating the draw back threat.”
***
Commanders’ cope with edge rusher Odafe Oweh not as widespread, although
Williams: On the opposite finish of the spectrum, the agent pointed to former Los Angeles Chargers edge rusher Odafe Oweh signing a four-year, $100 million cope with the Washington Commanders that features $68 million in assured cash.
Odafe Oweh is one in all 12 edge rushers who now has a contract price at the very least $100 million in whole worth. (Picture by Katelyn Mulcahy/Getty Photographs)
Oweh, 27, completed with 7.5 sacks in 12 video games with the Chargers are going and not using a sack within the first 5 video games of the 2025 season with Baltimore, taking part in 513 snaps between stints with the Ravens and Chargers final season after a midseason commerce to L.A. Washington seems to be betting on the potential of a breakout marketing campaign for Oweh, however the agent I spoke with has reservations.
“There’s a cause Baltimore traded him to the Chargers final season,” the agent informed me. “Furthermore, I’m unsure that his one yr of manufacturing in Los Angeles [relative to his lack of production in Baltimore] equates to $25 million a yr to me.”
